Disclosure: When you buy through links on this site, we may earn a commission.

Disclosure: Watchdog Labs is free to use. When you buy through links on this site, we may earn a commission.

Dog Food Ratings

Please be aware that Hill’s is voluntarily recalling some canned dog food due to potentially elevated levels of Vitamin D. More information here.

Purina ONE SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Adult Formula Dry Dog Food

by Purina
TOP PICK
Review Product PhotoReview Product Photo
CHECK PRICE NOW
Review Summary

30 Second Summary

March 7, 2019
Updated

Purina ONE SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Adult Formula is a low-priced dog food with overall lower quality. This product has 5 controversial ingredients, including artificial color and flavor. The food has a somewhat high amount of carbs, compared to its protein and fat with excellent meat and fat quality. Purina has an above-average number of recalls. The company was relatively transparent when answering our questions.

Read the Full Review Below
TYPE
Dry Dog Food
PRICE
$
BREED SIZE
Small, Medium, Large Breeds
AGE
Adult
FEATURES
-
PACKAGE
8, 16.5, 31.1, 40 lbs
MADE IN
United States
COMPANY
Nestle Purina PetCare

Created By Dog Lovers Like You

Product Reviews
3,173 Dog Foods
Reviewed
Expert Interviews
11 Experts
Interviewed
Dog Food Research
900+ Hours
of Research
Independent
100% Independent
& Zero Ads
Just Getting Started?

Just Getting Started?

Learn what makes a great dog food and get expert advice on how to choose the best food for your dog.

Learn MoreJust Getting Started?

Meet Our Team & Advisors

This dog food review was created by experts who love dogs. Find out more about our team and mission.

About Watchdog Labs
Nutrition

Nutrition

This food is somewhat high in carbs, which is lowering the protein and fat content slightly, making it less nutritionally balanced compared to other dog foods we evaluated. Carbohydrates are cheap so they keep the food’s cost low. They are nutritionally useful to dogs in the right amounts, however, high amounts of carbs can reduce the much-needed meat-based protein and fat content.

To evaluate dog foods, we first calculate out the moisture. This is called the “dry matter basis” and shows you only the solid ingredients in the food. These estimated “dry matter” numbers are different from the food label, but a better way to understand the real nutritional value of the food. We also calculate the carbs. Find out more

Label Claim

Dry Matter

Min. Protein 29.55%

Min. Fat 18.18%

Min. Carbs 44.32%

Max. Fiber 3.41%

Max. Ash 7.95%

Max. Moisture 0.00%

Label Claim

Food Label

Min. Protein: 26.0%

Min Fat: 16.0%

Min Carbs: N/A

Max Fiber: 3.0%

Max Ash: N/A

Max. Moisture: 12.0%

Calories

Calories

380 Calories per Cup

This product has an average amount of calories. It’s important to understand how many calories you are feeding to prevent under or overfeeding. Average calorie foods like this are typically best for fairly active dogs who need a moderate amount of daily calories. Based on your dog's current weight and activity level you may want to feed more or less than the recommended amount. It's helpful to know that weight loss foods often have fewer than 340 calories per cup, weight maintenance foods typically range from 340-380 calories, and high-activity dog foods are usually over 400 calories.

FDA Alert

Help Other Dogs

Share Watchdog With Your Friends

Share
Share
Share
Share
FDA Alert

FDA Alert

Grain-Free Dog Foods

This is a grain-free dog food. The FDA is investigating a potential connection between grain-free diets and canine heart disease. There is not enough evidence yet to affect our ratings but we've created an article for you explaining the topic.

Learn More
50.7%
WATCHDOG
SCORE
Score BannerOverall Rating Score
Ingredients

Ingredients

Score
45%
39
Total Ingredients
5
Controversial Ingredients

Lamb (Source of Glucosamine), Rice Flour, Whole Grain Corn, Whole Grain Wheat, Chicken By-Product Meal (Source of Glucosamine), Corn Gluten Meal, Soybean Meal, Beef Fat Naturally Preserved with Mixed-Tocopherols, Mono and Dicalcium Phosphate, Glycerin, Calcium Carbonate, Liver Flavor, Salt, Caramel Color, Soybean Oil, Potassium Chloride, Dried Carrots, Dried Peas, Vitamins [Vitamin E Supplement, Niacin (Vitamin B-3), Vitamin A Supplement, Calcium Pantothenate (Vitamin B-5), Thiamine Mononitrate (Vitamin B-1), Vitamin B-12 Supplement, Riboflavin Supplement (Vitamin B-2), Pyridoxine Hydrochloride (Vitamin B-6), Folic Acid (Vitamin B-9), Menadione Sodium Bisulfite Complex (Vitamin K), Vitamin D-3 Supplement, Biotin (Vitamin B-7)], Minerals [Zinc Sulfate, Ferrous Sulfate, Manganese Sulfate, Copper sulfate, Calcium Iodate, Sodium Selenite], Choline Chloride, L-Lysine Monohydrochloride, Sulfur.

The average dog food we reviewed has 39 total ingredients, with 1 controversial ingredient. This product has 5 total controversial ingredients and 2 of them are found in the first five ingredients. This is concerning because the first 5 ingredients make up most of the product.


Top 5 Ingredients

Dog food ingredients are listed in descending order of weight. So when looking at a dog food label, take a close look at the first 5 ingredients. They make up about 80% of the total weight.


  • Lamb (Source of Glucosamine)
    Lamb is generally a healthy dog food ingredient. Raw meat contains about 75% water which is cooked off during the making of dog food. This leaves only a fraction of the protein content in the final product's weight. We recommend looking for dog foods that also include meat meals in the first five ingredients (pre-cooked meat powder that contains four times the amount of protein). Glucosamine is a combination of glutamine (an amino acid) and glucose (a sugar) that's present in chicken.
  • Rice Flour
    Rice flour provides calories, complex carbohydrates and a few other nutrients to dogs. We generally consider it a quality dog food ingredient.
  • Whole Grain Corn
    Corn (also known as maize) is a cereal grain that provides carbs, protein, fat, vitamin B and other nutrients. Because corn in dog food is an inexpensive (and often feed-grade quality) ingredient, we do not consider it a high-quality dog food ingredient.
  • Whole Grain Wheat
    Whole grain means that all three edible parts of the kernel (bran, germ, and endosperm) are kept before milling, which means more protein and nutrients are in the final product. Wheat is a grass and cereal grain often used in dog food. It provides protein, dietary fiber, manganese, phosphorus, niacin, B vitamins and minerals. Some dogs may develop wheat allergies, though they are a lot less common than allergies to beef, dairy and soy. The jury is still out on whether wheat is a high-quality dog food ingredient so please consult your vet if you suspect your dog may be allergic or has food sensitivities. Grain-alternatives like potatoes, peas and legumes may be linked to canine heart disease (it's too early to say this conclusively), so keep that in mind when buying foods without wheat and other grains.
  • Chicken By-Product Meal (Source of Glucosamine)
    Meat by-products are animal parts other than meat that are left over at the slaughterhouse. This can include the lung, spleen, brain, liver, blood, bone, beaks, kidneys, fatty tissue, and intestines. Because there is a wide variety of animal parts companies can use, and because details don't need to be disclosed, it's tough to compare the quality of different by-products. Generally speaking, by-products can provide important nutrients for dogs but can be of lower quality than meats and meat meals. For these reasons, we do not consider this a high-quality ingredient. Glucosamine is a combination of glutamine (an amino acid) and glucose (a sugar) that's present in chicken.

Controversial Ingredients

  1. Whole Grain Corn
  2. Whole grain corn is a low-cost dog food ingredient that provides energy (calories), but some dogs can be sensitive to it. Corn is not generally considered a controversial ingredient, but is controversial if it is used in the top five ingredients (which make up about 80% of the food's weight) where a named meat or lean protein would be more nutritious.
  1. Whole Grain Wheat
  2. Whole Grain Wheat is not simply good or bad as a dog food ingredient. It's a lower cost ingredient that does provide calories, but some dogs can be sensitive to it. Wheat is not generally considered a controversial ingredient, but is controversial when it is used in the top five ingredients (which make up about 80% of the food's weight) where a named meat or lean protein would be more nutritious.
  1. Liver Flavor
  2. Artificial flavors are added to increase the chance your dog will want to eat the food. The generic term artificial flavor is used to represent a large number of possible additives, some which could be harmful. These flavors may include but not list controversial ingredients such as propylene glycol, BHA and more.
  1. Caramel Color
  2. A concentrated form of caramel used in pet food to change the color of the food. It contains 4-methylimidazole (4-MIE), which has been shown to potentially produce cancer in animals.
  1. Menadione Sodium Bisulfite Complex (Vitamin K)
  2. A synthetic version of Vitamin K (known as Menadione) which is added due to the lack or loss of Vitamin K in the food processing. Menadione supplements are banned by the FDA because of their potential toxicity in human use and can be found as 10+ different names on a label. While low amounts have been found to be safe, the consistent repetitive nature of a dogs diet results in the long-term exposure that should be considered.


Country of Origin

This Purina pet food is made in the United States. That’s a very good thing, because it means the company has to follow strict dog food safety standards when making the food. We generally recommend buying dog foods made in the USA, Canada, Europe, New Zealand or Australia for that reason.


Meat & Fat Quality

The meats and added oils here are Lamb, Chicken By-Product Meal, Beef Fat and Soybean Oil. All of them are great because they show you which animals (and plant) they come from, well done.


Artificial Preservatives

This product has no controversial artificial preservatives. If you’d like to know more about this topic: It’s good to know that ‍not all artificial preservatives are bad. That’s because they serve an important purpose, which is to prevent food from spoiling. However, we consider 11 artificial preservatives controversial because of their potential link to cancer and other serious health conditions.


Artificial Colors

This dog food contains Caramel Color, a controversial artificial color. We describe more details above.


Artificial Flavors

As mentioned above, this food has added artificial Liver Flavor. It’s a controversial and unnecessary ingredient and the product would be better without it.

Recalls

Recalls

Score
65%
3
Brand Recalls

Purina has an above-average number of dog food recalls.

Date:
3/9/2016
Recalled Products:
Beneful Prepared Meals Roasted Chicken Recipe canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-10764 and Canada UPC 55800 10554. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals Beef Stew canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with Canada UPC 55800 11651. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Chopped Blends 6-count variety pack containing wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs: 2 tubs lamb, 2 tubs chicken, and 2 tubs beef with UPC 17800 - 16627. Product is shipped in cases of 6 packs. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Chopped Blends Chicken and Liver canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-16960. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals 12-count variety pack containing wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs: 4 tubs savory rice and lamb stew, 4 tubs chicken stew, and 4 tubs beef stew with UPC 17800 - 16814. Product is shipped in cases of 12 packs. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. less... Beneful Chopped Blends Lamb canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-15498 and Canada UPC 55800-21238. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals 6-count variety pack containing wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs: 2 tubs savory rice and lamb stew, 2 tubs chicken stew, and 2 tubs beef stew with UPC 17800 - 15030. Product is shipped in cases of 6 packs. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. less... Beneful Prepared Meals Beef Stew canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-10965. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Chopped Blends Salmon canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-16962. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals Simmered Beef canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with Canada UPC 55800 11649. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals Simmered Beef Entree' canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with UPC 17800-10963. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals Roasted Turkey Medley canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-10968 and Canada UPC 55800-11562. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Chopped Blends Chicken canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-15496 and Canada UPC 55800-21254. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals Beef and Chicken Recipe canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-12859. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Chopped Blends Beef canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-15494. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Chopped Blends Turkey canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-16966. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals Chicken Stew canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-12861 and Canada UPC 55800-11564. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals Savory Rice and Lamb Stew canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-10967 and Canada UPC 55800 10556. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Beneful Prepared Meals Simmered Chicken Medley canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with US UPC 17800-10964 and Canada UPC 55800-10549. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Pro Plan Savory Meals braised beef canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with UPC 38100-16143. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Pro Plan Savory Meals grilled salmon canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with UPC 38100-16155. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Pro Plan Savory Meals braised pork canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with UPC 38100-16151. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Pro Plan Savory Meals braised turkey canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with UPC 38100-16147. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164. Pro Plan Savory Meals braised chicken canned wet dog food packaged in 10 oz. plastic tubs with UPC 38100-16148. Product is shipped 8 tubs per case. Manufactured by Nestle Purina PetCare Company, St. Louis, MO 63164.
Cause:
Product may contain less vitamins and minerals than label purports.
Class:
II
FDA recalls use classes from I (most serious) to III (least serious).
Type:
Voluntary
Quantity:
945,493 total cases
Source
Date:
3/30/2007
Recalled Products:
Canned dog food with Best By date of Feb. 2009 in the following varieties and sizes: Alpo Prime Cuts Chicken & Rice, 22 oz cans, Alpo Lean Prime Cuts, 13.2 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Beef, 13.2 oz cans; 22 oz cans and 4.95 lb can, Alpo Prime Cuts Beef & Liver, 13.2 oz cans and 22 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Chicken, 13.2 oz cans and 22 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Turkey Bacon, 13.2 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Beef Stew, 13.2 oz cans and 22 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Gourmet Dinner, 13.2 oz cans and 22 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Beef Bacon Cheese, 13.2 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts London Grill, 13.2 oz cans and 22 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Senior Beef & Rice, 13.2 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts/Entree Chicken Vegetable, 13.2 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Beef & Rice, 13.2 oz cans and 22 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Lamb & Rice, 13.2 oz cans and 22 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Beef Vegetable, 13.2 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Variety Pack, 12 count, 13.2 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Variety Pack, 8 count, 22 oz cans, Alpo Prime Cuts Variety Pack, 24 count, 13.2 oz cans.
Cause:
Wheat gluten containing melamine.
Class:
I
FDA recalls use classes from I (most serious) to III (least serious).
Type:
N/A
Quantity:
N/A
Source
Date:
3/16/2007
Recalled Products:
5.3 oz. Mighty Dog pouch products (including multi-pack pouch products) manufactured from Dec. 3, 2006 through March 14, 2007, with a Product Code #6337 through #7073 and Plant Code #1798.
Cause:
Melamine.
Class:
I
FDA recalls use classes from I (most serious) to III (least serious).
Type:
N/A
Quantity:
N/A
Source
Transparency

Transparency

Score
72%

We love dog food brands that are committed to transparent business practices. If you make quality dog food you should be willing to openly talk about how it’s sourced and produced. That’s why we reached out to pet food companies, asking questions about all their brands and products. Each company had three weeks to reply to our messages.

How Easy Was it to Reach the Company?

Purina Pro is owned by the multinational company Nestlé Purina. It required two emails over two weeks to get the answers below. Like most large companies, many of the customer service answers will read like well-crafted marketing messages.    

Does Purina ONE (Nestlé Purina) have a veterinary nutritionist on staff? If so, who are they?

At Nestlé Purina, we have over 500 nutritionists, veterinarians and scientists who work daily to formulate and make quality changes to our products. We also staff quality control specialists at all of our manufacturing plants that run over 100 quality and safety checks during the manufacturing of our formulas.

This lengthy answer did not answer the specific question that was asked. In addition, the names of the professionals could not be provided.  

Who formulates your recipes, and what are their credentials?

(see the previous answers)

Do you test your products using AAFCO feeding trials? Why, or why not?

All of our products are manufactured following stringent guidelines approved by the USDA and AAFCO, and our Purina® Pro Plan® brand Pet Food products have undergone the AAFCO feeding studies for quality, safety, digestibility and palatability.

Since this representative is responding on behalf of a family of brands, they have referenced a few of the other brands that do the feeding trials, but they were not clear if the Purina ONE line does the feeding trials.  

What country are your products manufactured?

The vast majority of our products are manufactured in the US, at Nestlé Purina owned facilities, with ingredients sourced from the US as well.

The vast majority does not mean “all” which is less clear than it could have been.  

Can your manufacturing facilities be visited?

Unfortunately, we do not offer public access to our manufacturing plants at this time, and apologize for any inconvenience this may cause.

What quality measures do you use to assure consistency and quality?

We also staff quality control specialists at all of our manufacturing plants that run over 100 quality and safety checks during the manufacturing of our formulas.

This is good, but not as not as clear as it could be.  

Does Purina ONE (Nestlé Purina) own its manufacturing facility? If it is another company, what company is it?

Yes.


Do any parts of your product come from China?

A very small number of ingredients are sourced from China, however, these are mainly vitamins and minerals, such as taurine and Vitamin B12, that are not readily available in the US in the quantities we need.

Sourcing quality ingredients at scale is a significant challenge that many large companies will cite. This means that companies like Nestlé who are supplying massive distribution channels will often use a variety of sourcing options, including China.


Purina ONE SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Adult Formula Dry Dog Food

by Purina
CHECK PRICE NOW
Other Products From This Brand

Other Food From This Brand

Educational Resources

Educational Resources

Sources

Sources

Disclaimer

Made with love in Cambridge, MA.
© 2019 Watchdog Labs Inc. All rights reserved.

Watchdog Labs, Watchdog Score and watchdoglabs.com are trademarks of Watchdog Labs Inc.

Disclaimer

DISCLAIMER: All content on this website, including but not limited to statements about products are to be construed as opinions only. All statements made by or associated with Watchdog Labs, Inc., including but not limited to text, graphics, videos, web content, social media content, e-mails, marketing and informational materials, advertisements, statements made by company representatives, and repeated statements which originated from third-party sources are to be construed as opinions only. Watchdog Labs, Inc. is not responsible for the quality or the veracity of statements or information from third-party sources. Third-party sources shall include but not be limited to labs, online stores, sellers, other websites, brands and manufacturers.

Disclaimer

DISCLAIMER: Our reviews and testing are necessarily limited in scope, and products may vary significantly from one package to another and from one store to another. We may only test one batch of a product from one store and not all reviewed products have undergone lab tests. Our opinion is based on that limited testing.

Disclaimer

DISCLAIMER: These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration or the Association of American Feed Control Officials. Products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Always consult your veterinary professional before choosing any products for your pet.

Disclaimer

DISCLAIMER: Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and different information than what is shown on this website. Always read all labels, warnings, and directions before using a product.

Disclaimer

DISCLOSURE: When readers buy products on this site, we earn a commission that supports our work.

Disclaimer

Watchdog Labs is not affiliated, associated, authorized by, endorsed by, or in any way connected to the brands and companies mentioned on this website. All trademarks, copyrights, and other rights are the property of their respective owners. See our Terms of Service for DMCA notices.

Disclaimer

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. All prices on this site may change and those considered valid are displayed on Amazon.com